The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
A Bridge Blog
Assigning blame since April 20, 2007

Revaluation

Print the article

This entry was posted on 9/9/2007 11:05 AM and is filed under The Bad.

Here's a not-so-great hand from my set with Wayne.

3rd seat, all red
 
T53 / K7 / 94 / AKT753
 
2 passes to you
 
1 Club or 3? (or 1NT?!?) 
 
Let's say you bid 1 Club.  Lefty bids 1 Heart.  Pard bids 1 Spade (showing 5+).  Righty bids 2 Hearts.

What now?

To me, this is an automatic support double.  Sure, you don't like your Heart King so much any more (though just because Lefty probably has 5 Hearts and Righty probably has 3 doesn't mean the Ace is always on your left or that partner doesn't have either the Ace or Queen) but pard is a passed hand, so he's unlikely to hang you, and who wants to defend 2 Hearts with (potentially) half the deck and a known 8 card Spade fit?

Wayne chose to pass, though.  Now I have to decide whether to balance back in with

AQJ87 / J65 / J32 / Q9  (white I'd have opened 2 Spades)

opposite a partner who's ostensibly denied 3 Spades.

Looks like a 15 trick hand.  Pard is probably 2-2-4-5 or something like that.  He might even be 2-3-3-5 (4 card overcall or a raise on honor doubleton.)  At matchpoints, I might try to push them up a level, but at IMPs, it looks normal to pass and take my probable -110 instead of my -100 or -200 in 2 Spades.  If I think this is worth a 2 Spade bid now that I know we don't have a fit, I should have opened 2 Spades.

I led the Queen of Clubs

K64 / 932 / AQT85 / 42 Dummy (LHO)

AQJ87 / J65 / J32 / Q9

My Queen held, Wayne encouraging, so I knew he didn't have a stiff Spade (else he would likely scream for a switch.)  It looked like my only chance was to play the Queen of Spades (preferably without tanking forever) and hope Declarer guessed wrong.

Success!  My Queen of Spades held the trick and I patted myself on the back for passing 2 Hearts as we were now headed for +100.  Ace of Spades. Spade ruff. Ace of Clubs. Club uppercut.  NEXT

Of course, it didn't quite work out like that ... 

'huh?'

'should I still support Dbl with what is only a 7 count in the auction ?'

'only if you want a plus score'

Technically -140 is the par result, but I doubt either opp was bidding again over 2 Spades:

K64 / 932 / AQT85 / 42

92 / AQT84 / K76 / J86

Though to be fair, I'd have opened 3 Clubs with Wayne's hand and we'd have likely ended up -100 anyway, which is almost as bad.

-140 was 3 IMPs and change away

http://online.bridgebase.com/myhands/fetchlin.php?id=6954479&when_played=1186410446

 
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URL for this entry
  • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
Comments

    • 9/10/2007 11:51 AM Jeff wrote:
      Actually, standard treatment would probably be to raise with 3 pieces (since 1S showed 5) and make a support double with 2.
      Reply to this
    • 9/10/2007 12:00 PM Jonathan Ferguson wrote:
      Yeah, Wayne broke tempo a little bit over 2 Hearts (which made it even harder for me to balance back in) and I figured his problem probably was whether a support double shows 2 card support or not.

      I'm sure lots of people play it both ways. It doesn't feel right to make a support double with xx, even opposite a known 5 bagger.
      Reply to this
    Leave a comment

     Enter the above security code (required)

     Name

     Email (will not be published)

     Website

    Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.