Just finished a fun 12 board team match with that guy I went plus on all 9 boards in in a tournament a few months back (I doubt I have any readers that faithful, but you never know.) I declared the first 3 hands and 2 after that, each one of which was very interesting.
3NT on the 5 of Spades lead with silent opps. 1H - 1S - 2C - 2D - 2N - 3N - Float
63 / AKT84 / K9 / AJ65
Is it right to play the Jack of Spades at trick 1?
1NT on the Jack of Hearts lead on the auction P-P-1S-1N-Float
85 / 84 / 75432 / KQ84
QJT / AK7 / AQJ / J652
Is it right to duck the opening lead (Righty played the 6, if that matters)?
3NT on the King of Hearts lead (ducked) and the Jack of Spades switch. 1N - P - 3N - Float
A854 / 85 / AJ432 / 97
KT72 / AJ3 / Q8 / AQ84
Where do you win the 2nd trick? How do you continue?
3NT on the 6 of Hearts lead (another 1N - 3N auction.)
KJT / J3 / J852 / K952
Q4 / A952 / AKT97 / A6
Do you play the Jack from dummy? If RHO inserts a cheap honor, do you win or duck?
3 Hearts on the 5 of Spades (likely singleton) lead. 1H - 2D (overcall) - 3H - Float
AJ8763 / T63 / - / J942
KQ2 / J9852 / 832 / AQ
Do you draw trumps and risk them cashing the first 6 tricks in the red suits? Do you try to ruff Diamonds? Do you take the Club finesse? Do you 'draw trumps' by leading Spades?
And finally ... 7 Diamonds on the Deuce of Diamonds lead. Uncontested 1C - 1D - 2C - 2S - 3D - 6D - 7D
AJ8 / 2 / 974 / AQ9763
K654 / A83 / AQJT3 / 8
Is a Club finesse in your immediate plans or not? If you don't take the Club finesse, and LHO follows with the JT of Clubs when you play a Club to the Ace and ruff a Club, then what?
Okay, you caught me, the last one was while playing with GIB (I was not sitting pretty, hence the 6 Diamond shot) but it's still an interesting declarer play problem.
3NT on the 5 of Spades lead with silent opps. 1H - 1S - 2C - 2D - 2N - 3N - Float
AKJ74 / 76 / QT6 / QT2
63 / AKT84 / K9 / AJ65
Is it right to play the Jack of Spades at trick 1?
Obviously if it was AKJx opposite 3 small the safety play for 3 tricks is to cash AK and then play a Spade up. But here the only holding where you really feel awful if you finesse is stiff Q offside (meaning opening leader has T9852, the 5 not being the likeliest of leads from that holding.) Against that, your dummy isn't exactly crawling with entries and if you don't take the hook early, then what? If you play a Club honor, LHO can duck once and then win the 2nd one and you might never see the board again (unless you never take the Spade hook, but you've got to set up a 9th trick somewhere to go with your 2 Spades, 2 Hearts, 1 Diamond and 3 Clubs.)
I think it's right to pay off to stiff Q and take the Spade hook right away. On the actual hand, that's what I did. It lost to RHO and he returned a Diamond (from Jack 5th.) The Club hook was off so I scored the obvious 9 tricks (2, 2, 2, 3.) +400 was a push
LHO
52 / J9532 / A74 / K83
RHO
QT98 / Q / J8532 / 974
1NT on the Jack of Hearts lead on the auction P-P-1S-1N-Float
85 / 84 / 75432 / KQ84
QJT / AK7 / AQJ / J652
Is it right to duck the opening lead (Righty played the 6, if that matters)?
You'd like to duck if you were sure that LHO would continue Hearts. The 6 looks nebulous enough that that's likely. Ducking protects against 6-2 Hearts (when you win the 2nd Heart and play a Club up, RHO won't have any Hearts to return.)
But if LHO switches to a Spade, you're down if Spades are 6-2 (which is not unlikely since there wasn't a Spade lead originally.)
I ducked. Spades were 6-2 AND Hearts were 6-2. But LHO had no entry whatsoever (1 count) so the duck wasn't necessary (and would have been fatal if they had found the Spade switch.) They continued Hearts and I eventually took 7 tricks (I declined the Diamond finesse since in the unlikely event that it lost, I would have been down a couple.)
Conclusion: On this one, against an expert pair, you win the first Heart and hope the Diamond hook is on (you have 7 top tricks in that case once you drive out the Club.) Against a not-so-strong pair, I think ducking has a lot of merit. +90 was lose 1 (I could have made 5 if I had been willing to risk the Diamond finesse after RHO ducked a Spade to me ... sigh)
LHO
93 / JT9532 / T96 / 97
RHO
AK7642 / Q6 / K8 / AT3
3NT on the King of Hearts lead (ducked) and the Jack of Spades switch. 1N - P - 3N - Float
A854 / 85 / AJ432 / 97
KT72 / AJ3 / Q8 / AQ84
Where do you win the 2nd trick? How do you continue?
I decided to believe my opponent and I won the Ace and started to run the 8, but I hated killing that late Spade entry to dummy, so I continued with a low Spade. RHO took me off the guess by playing the Queen! and I won the King as LHO followed with the 9. Now I continued with the Queen of Diamonds, covered, which I ducked. LHO switched in desperation to a Club and when Diamonds were 3-3, I had 11 tricks. Fun hand. +460 was win 2.
LHO
J9 / KQT72 / KT6 / K65
RHO
Q63 / 964 / 975 / JT32
3NT on the 6 of Hearts lead (another 1N - 3N auction.)
KJT / J3 / J852 / K952
Q4 / A952 / AKT97 / A6
Do you play the Jack from dummy? If RHO inserts a cheap honor, do you win or duck?
I was really thrown by this suit combination. Obviously with A852 (or worse) your only chance is to try the Jack and with AT52, you must play low from dummy.
I eventually concluded that playing low is right. Obviously playing the Jack gets you a trick and a tempo if opening leader has KQ86 or some such, but if he has KT864 and you play the Jack, you now have to duck when RHO plays the Queen, or down you go if RHO gets in with the Ace of Spades.
It turned out not to matter when RHO showed up with QT tight. The opponents were unable to attack Hearts successfully, so scored only their 4 obvious tricks (1 Spade, 2 Hearts, 1 Diamond (Qxx offside.) +600 was win 12 (the other declarer couldn't count, or something, he had 9 top tricks on a Spade lead.)
LHO
752 / K8764 / Q64 / QT
RHO
A9863 / QT / 3 / J8743
3 Hearts on the 5 of Spades (likely singleton) lead. 1H - 2D (overcall) - 3H - Float
AJ8763 / T63 / - / J942
KQ2 / J9852 / 832 / AQ
Do you draw trumps and risk them cashing the first 6 tricks in the red suits? Do you try to ruff Diamonds? Do you take the Club finesse? Do you 'draw trumps' by leading Spades?
I took what appears to be the 'normal' line of ruff a Diamond, hook a Club, ruff a Diamond, club to Ace, ruff last Diamond, exhale. I ended up making 3 (I should have made 4 on a misdefense.) Drawing trumps obviously doesn't work (even though they block, they'll still score 3 trumps and 2 Diamonds.) Leading Spades doesn't seem to make much sense, but you can get away with it this time on the lie of the cards. +140 was lose 10 (our teammates lost their way defending 4 Hearts doubled when declarer led trumps after the same Spade lead. RHO returned a Club when in with the first trump and a Spade when in with the 2nd. Ouch.)
LHO
5 / K74 / AQT754 / 765
RHO
T94 / AQ / KJ96 / KT83
And finally ... 7 Diamonds on the Deuce of Diamonds lead. Uncontested 1C - 1D - 2C - 2S - 3D - 6D - 7D
AJ8 / 2 / 974 / AQ9763
K654 / A83 / AQJT3 / 8
Is a Club finesse in your immediate plans or not? If you don't take the Club finesse, and LHO follows with the JT of Clubs when you play a Club to the Ace and ruff a Club, then what?
I really wanted to make this hand. Would have earned its own entry if I had. I played the 9 from dummy and RHO played the King. First problem solved. Now what?
My first mistake was not ruffing a Heart right away. I thought I might as well use the Ace of Clubs as an entry now and save the Heart ruffs for entries later. I played Club to Ace, Lefty followed with the Ten, ruffed a Club, Lefty followed with the Jack, and played the Ace of Hearts and ruffed a Heart. The only way to make it now on the actual lie is to draw trumps and take the Spade finesse to run the ruffing Club hook through RHO.
Instead, I ruffed a Club and LHO showed out.
AJ8 / - / 7 / Q97
K654 / 8 / QJ / -
If I'd ruffed that Heart earlier, I could still make it if Spades were 3-3 with Q onside, but I've managed to block the suit on this line so down I go. Sigh.
LHO
Q932 / KJT4 / 652 / JT
RHO
T7 / Q9765 / K8 / K542